# IP Checkers Compared: ipinfo vs Scamalytics

> ipinfo and IP2Location say where an IP is; Scamalytics scores its traffic. We read 4 addresses on 4 checkers: same country 16 of 16 times, cities differ.

[Home](https://quanticdata.io/) / [Blog](https://quanticdata.io/blog/) / IP Checkers Compared: ipinfo vs Scamalytics

# IP checkers compared: ipinfo, IP2Location, ip-api and Scamalytics

Proxies · Nov 20, 2026 · 6 min read · By [Aldo Morese](https://quanticdata.io/about/), founder of QuanticData

![Four public addresses read on four IP checkers on 20 November 2026: ipinfo, IP2Location, ip-api and Scamalytics. The country was the same in 16 of 16 answers, the city of one address came back as four different cities, and the fraud scores were 16 for a home provider address and 0 for a datacenter address.](https://quanticdata.io/blog/ip-checkers-compared/hero.webp?v=20261120h)

On this page

- [Two kinds of checker](https://quanticdata.io/blog/ip-checkers-compared/#two-kinds-of-checker)
- [What we measured: four addresses on four checkers](https://quanticdata.io/blog/ip-checkers-compared/#what-we-measured-four-addresses-on-four-checkers)
- [The country and the network agree](https://quanticdata.io/blog/ip-checkers-compared/#the-country-and-the-network-agree)
- [The city is an estimate](https://quanticdata.io/blog/ip-checkers-compared/#the-city-is-an-estimate)
- [The score is not the type](https://quanticdata.io/blog/ip-checkers-compared/#the-score-is-not-the-type)
- [IPQS and Scamalytics: why the numbers differ](https://quanticdata.io/blog/ip-checkers-compared/#ipqs-and-scamalytics-why-the-numbers-differ)
- [One rule: look the address up from outside](https://quanticdata.io/blog/ip-checkers-compared/#one-rule-look-the-address-up-from-outside)
- [Which checker to use for a proxy](https://quanticdata.io/blog/ip-checkers-compared/#which-checker-to-use-for-a-proxy)

IP checkers answer two different questions. ipinfo, IP2Location and ip-api are location and network databases: they say where an address is and who operates it. Scamalytics and IPQualityScore (IPQS) are risk scorers: they estimate how much of the traffic from an address looks fraudulent. One address can read differently on each.

**Run it on the free credit.** Every QuanticData account gets $2 of free API usage per month.

[Start free — $2/month included](https://quanticdata.io/signup/?utm_source=blog&utm_medium=website&utm_campaign=blog-lead&utm_content=ip-checkers-compared) · [Explore ISP Proxies from $2.50/IP in 61 Countries](https://quanticdata.io/isp-proxies/)

To show what that means in practice, on 20 November 2026 we looked up the same four public addresses on four checkers and compared every field. The addresses are DNS resolvers that their operators publish: one from Comcast, one from Deutsche Telekom, Google's 8.8.8.8 and one from Hetzner. Two sit on home provider networks, two in datacenters.

## Two kinds of checker

| Checker | Kind | What it returns |
| --- | --- | --- |
| ipinfo | Location and network | Country, region, city, the network with its ASN, the reverse DNS name |
| IP2Location | Location and network | Country, region, city, the network, a proxy flag |
| ip-api | Location and network | Country, region, city, the network, and three flags: mobile, proxy, hosting |
| Scamalytics | Risk score | A fraud score from 0 to 100, a datacenter field, proxy fields and five blacklists |
| IPQS | Risk score | A fraud score with connection and abuse signals; request settings such as strictness can affect the result (as our product pages describe it; not part of the run below) |

The first group describes the address. The second group judges traffic, which is why two scorers can disagree: each builds its number from its own traffic, its own lists and its own model. Other checkers that customers send us, ping0 among them, are read the same way: first decide which kind of answer each field is.

## What we measured: four addresses on four checkers

| Address | ipinfo | IP2Location | ip-api | Scamalytics |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Comcast resolver, 75.75.75.75 | US, Mount Laurel, AS7922 Comcast | US, Cambridge, Comcast | US, Canton, AS7922 Comcast; hosting false | US, Northlake; score 16; datacenter No |
| Deutsche Telekom resolver, 194.25.0.60 | DE, Hannover, AS3320 Deutsche Telekom | DE, Hanover, Deutsche Telekom | DE, Hanover, AS3320; hosting false | DE, Hanover; score 2; datacenter Unknown |
| Google, 8.8.8.8 | US, Mountain View, AS15169 Google | US, Mountain View, Google | US, Ashburn, AS15169; hosting true | US, Mountain View; score 0; datacenter Yes |
| Hetzner resolver, 185.12.64.1 | DE, Gunzenhausen | DE, Gunzenhausen, Hetzner | DE, Gunzenhausen; hosting true | DE, Gunzenhausen; score 5; datacenter Yes |

Each lookup was made from our own connection, with the address in the URL, on ipinfo.io, IP2Location.io, ip-api.com and scamalytics.com. Three things stand out.

## The country and the network agree

The country was the same in 16 of 16 answers, and so was the operator's name wherever a checker returned one. These two fields come from the address registries and from the routing table, which every database reads. When you check a proxy, they are the fields to read first: the country tells you whether the targeting worked, and the network tells you what kind of address it is.

## The city is an estimate

For the Comcast resolver the four checkers named four cities: Mount Laurel, Cambridge, Canton and Northlake. That address is announced from many places at once, which ipinfo marks with `anycast: true`, so there is no single right city. For the Deutsche Telekom address all four said Hanover. City data is each database's own estimate; our [proxy location checker](https://quanticdata.io/tools/proxy-location-checker/) shows seven databases next to each other for that reason.

For the proxies you buy from us, the reference is stated in our Terms: the country and city of an IP are the ones ipinfo shows. A site that reads another database can show another city for the same address.

**Try it on your own targets.** Every QuanticData account gets $2 of free API usage per month.

[Start free — $2/month included](https://quanticdata.io/signup/?utm_source=blog&utm_medium=website&utm_campaign=blog-inline&utm_content=ip-checkers-compared) · [Explore ISP Proxies from $2.50/IP in 61 Countries](https://quanticdata.io/isp-proxies/)

## The score is not the type

On Scamalytics, Google's datacenter address scored 0 and the Comcast home provider address scored 16. Both are rated low risk, and the order is the opposite of what many people expect. The score measures suspicious traffic seen from an address and its network; it does not say whether the address is a home line or a server. That is a separate field: Scamalytics answered datacenter No for Comcast and Yes for Google and Hetzner, and ip-api's hosting flag split the four addresses the same way, false for the two home providers and true for the two datacenters.

So read a risk checker in two steps: the type fields first, the score second. Our own [IP fraud score check](https://quanticdata.io/tools/ip-fraud-score-check/) is laid out that way, with the score, the flags and five blacklists in one view; in its published sample a Comcast resolver also scored 17 while two Tor exits scored 0.

## IPQS and Scamalytics: why the numbers differ

Our run read the four checkers in the table above; what follows on IPQS is how our own product pages and Terms describe it. Both services give a fraud score where lower is better, and the similarity ends there. Scamalytics states on each result how it got the number: for the Comcast address it had no visibility of that single IP and applied the score of the operator's network. IPQS returns its score with connection and abuse signals, and its request settings, strictness among them, can affect the assessment. A fair comparison over time keeps the same checker and the same settings, and records the date.

That is also why a plan names its checker. Where one of our plans says Fraud score 0, each IP is checked on IPQualityScore right before delivery and has a score of 0 at that moment, as our Terms state; on our [low fraud score ISP proxies](https://quanticdata.io/isp-proxies/low-fraud-score/), low fraud score is the overall description of the IPs across checkers, not a promise of zero on every one. Scores move with time and with use, so check the one your application depends on.

## One rule: look the address up from outside

Scoring sites log the visits they receive. If you open one in a browser that is using the proxy, the proxy's address becomes one more visitor in their data. Read the exit address first, then look it up from another connection: put the address in the checker's URL, or use our tools, which look it up from our servers.

```bash
# 1. read the exit address through the proxy
curl -s -x http://USER:PASS@HOST:PORT https://api.ipify.org

# 2. look it up from your own connection
curl -s https://ipinfo.io/203.0.113.10/json
```

Replace the example address with your exit. The fields of the answer are explained one by one in [how to check a proxy IP](https://quanticdata.io/how-to-check-proxy-ip/).

## Which checker to use for a proxy

- **Is the IP in the right country?** ipinfo, then the [proxy location checker](https://quanticdata.io/tools/proxy-location-checker/) to see six more databases. We read one of our own ISP exits that way on 20 November 2026: 7 of 7 databases placed it in the United States.
- **Whose network is it?** The ASN on ipinfo or ip-api. On [city and carrier plans](https://quanticdata.io/isp-proxies/city-carrier-targeting/) you pick the carrier by its ASN before you pay.
- **Home line, mobile or server?** The type fields: mobile and hosting on ip-api, datacenter on Scamalytics.
- **How does a risk system rate it?** The scorer your target relies on, with fixed settings. Our [mobile proxy fraud score test](https://quanticdata.io/blog/mobile-proxies-fraud-score-tested/) shows what one network scored on 55 exits.

Then pick the network for the job: [residential proxies](https://quanticdata.io/residential-proxies/) for home IPs in many countries, mobile for carrier IPs, [ISP proxies](https://quanticdata.io/isp-proxies/) when one address has to stay the same for weeks.

### Sources & further reading

- [IPinfo: IP address data](https://ipinfo.io/)
- [IP2Location.io: IP geolocation API](https://www.ip2location.io/)
- [Scamalytics: IP address fraud check](https://scamalytics.com/ip)
- [IPQualityScore](https://www.ipqualityscore.com/)
- [RFC 8805: A Format for Self-Published IP Geolocation Feeds](https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8805)

## FAQ

Quick answers on ip checkers compared.

[Something else? Ask us](mailto:hello@quanticdata.io)

### What is the difference between IPQS and Scamalytics?

Both return a fraud score, each from its own traffic, lists and model, so the same IP can score differently. Scamalytics may apply the score of the operator's network, as it did for one address in our run; IPQS results can change with its request settings, strictness among them, so compare with fixed settings.

### Is ipinfo or IP2Location more accurate?

For the country they agree: in our run of 20 November 2026 four checkers gave the same country in 16 of 16 answers. The city is each database's estimate and can differ; for proxies bought from us, the reference in our Terms is ipinfo.

### What does a Scamalytics fraud score mean?

An estimate, from 0 to 100, of how much traffic from an address or its network looks fraudulent. It is not the address type: in our run a datacenter address scored 0 and a home provider address scored 16.

### Why do IP checkers show different cities for the same IP?

Each database builds its city data from its own sources. One address in our run came back as four cities on four checkers because it is announced from many places at once. The country matched on all four.

### Should I open a fraud score site through my proxy?

No. Those sites log every visit, so the proxy's address becomes part of their data. Read the exit address, then look it up from another connection or with a tool that queries from its own servers.

## Check an address on seven databases at once

The free proxy location checker and IP fraud score check look every address up from our servers.

[Start free — $2/month included](https://quanticdata.io/signup/?utm_source=blog&utm_medium=website&utm_campaign=blog-end&utm_content=ip-checkers-compared) · [Explore ISP Proxies from $2.50/IP in 61 Countries](https://quanticdata.io/isp-proxies/)

## Related reading

- [HTTP vs HTTPS: What a Proxy Sees in Each](https://quanticdata.io/blog/http-vs-https-proxy/): Proxies · HTTP sends requests as plain text; HTTPS wraps the same requests in TLS. We put a logging relay in front of a residential proxy line on 20 November 2026 and captured both: 340 readable bytes for http://, and for https:// one CONNECT line followed by 803 encrypted bytes.
- [Change Proxy IP by Link: Rotation Links](https://quanticdata.io/blog/change-proxy-ip-by-link/): Proxies · A rotation link is a URL that restarts one sticky session: open it and the session starts again; in our test of 20 November 2026 each of three calls was followed by a new exit IP. Below: the API call that creates the link, what it answered, the 10-second pause between rotations, and what to do on Mobile and Residential Premium.
- [ISP Proxy API: Stock, Quote and Buy by Code](https://quanticdata.io/blog/isp-proxy-api/): Proxies · The Premium ISP endpoints let a script do what the configurator does: read the catalog with live stock, pick a pool or a city and carrier, get a server-side quote and buy from the balance. Below: each call with the answer we got on 20 November 2026, what "currently unavailable" means, and how to write a buyer that never pays twice.

---

Source: https://quanticdata.io/blog/ip-checkers-compared/ · Site index for AI: https://quanticdata.io/llms.txt
